Animal Tail Plugs: Foxes and Kittens and Wolves, Oh My!

This post is going to review some of the best animal tail butt plugs available to buy.

We’ve looked at literally hundreds of tail plugs and sorted out the best and most popular options, as well as a handful of popular plugs to avoid.

Let’s get to it.

How to Pick the Best Animal Tail Butt Plug

What Kind of Animal Are You?

Picking the best animal tail butt plug is always going to be somewhat subjective.

Most of these plugs are identical in terms of shapes, materials, and sizes. That means the main differentiating factor is the aesthetics of your animal tail.

The most popular kinds of tail butt plugs are:

• Fox tails – Long, thick, bushy tails that range between 12″ – 30″ in length. Often come in a wide variety of colors and are the most popular type of tail plugs.
• Cat & kitten tails – Similar length and color options as fox tails, but usually less bushy with shorter fur.
• Wolf tails– Also similar fur to fox tails, however wolf tails tend to come in more traditional colors like brown, grey, red, and black.
• Pony plugs – Horse tail butt plugs are made with long, fine horse hairs that are much less fluffy than the tails above. Typically 10″ – 20″ in length.
• Bunny tails – A much shorter, furry pom-pom tail. Usually comes in a variety of bright colors.
• Dog and puppy tails – Quite different from the fur tails above. Typically a single piece of silicone, usually black.
• Curly pig tails – Similar to dog tails, pig tails are usually made of a single piece of silicone. These are usually a bit shorter at 6″ – 10″ in length and curly.

The best choice for you will be the one that fits your desired look and lets you unleash your inner animal!

Tail Plug Shape & Material

The majority of the tail butt plugs out there use a fairly standard “princess plug” shaped-bulb.

This is far from ideal for anal stimulation, compared to some of the best overall butt plugs out there.

That said, you’re buying a tail plug for the aesthetics, not the logistics! With that in mind, all these plugs need to do it sit snugly in place while you get wild with your partner.

As far as materials, the majority of plugs are one of three options:

• Silicone – soft, flexible, and great for leaving the plug in for longer periods of time.
• Stainless Steel – firm and shiny, provides unique sensations as the temperature of the metal changes.
• Glass – not as common as metal or silicone tail plugs, but glass butt plugs look & feel amazing in your ass.

Be wary of stainless steel tail plugs, as there are a lot of cheap “metal” butt plugs out there that are actually chrome-plated heavy metals, which should be avoided at all costs.

Good quality, body-safe tail butt plugs start at around $50 USD – anything cheaper than that is suspect to cutting corners somewhere in the production process and should probably be avoided.

Tail Materials

The overwhelming majority of tail plugs are made with faux fur for two reasons:

1. Cost – faux fur costs less and feels just as soft and fluffy as the real thing. This keeps toy prices lower for you.
2. Sustainability – faux fur is better for the animals and is more eco-friendly with regards to total impact on climate change.

That said, some plugs do advertise as being the real thing. We’ll do our best to call out which is which in our tail plug reviews below.

What Extra Features?

Few of these toys have additional features beyond the aesthetics of the tail, but there are a couple to keep an eye out for:

• Detachable Tail – for easy cleaning or just swapping out different looks with your favorite plug.
• Vibrations – because who doesn’t like a little extra stimulation?
• Matching accessories – to complete your newfound animal look.

Alright, let’s get to the best tail plug reviews!

Tail Plug Comparison Chart

Disclosure: some of the links on this page are affiliate links, meaning we get paid if you buy a product using one of our links, at no extra cost to you. We never let affiliate programs influence our decisions on the best sex toys, and the opinions here are our own. We’ve spent hundreds of hours reviewing and testing toys and this is how we keep the lights on. Read our full affiliate disclosure.

Best Overall Animal Tail Plugs: LovePlugs Collection

When it comes to choosing a best tail butt plug, there’s little doubt in our minds: the LovePlugs tail collections are the best there is.

They have one of the largest selections available in a variety of animal tails, and all plugs are well-built and feature body-safe materials.

Pros:

• Selection: 150+ different animals to choose from including fox tail plugs, kitten tail plugs, and more!
• Tail length: Huge variety of sizes, from a short 3″ rabbit tail to an extra-long 36″ fox tail plug.
• Materials: Most plugs are available in both silicone and stainless steel.
• Extended wear: Thin neck on the plug is comfortable for long-term roleplay.

Cons:

• No XL size: Most plugs come in small/medium/large, but there’s no XL size for the truly adventurous furry fetishist.

Final Review

The LovePlugs animal tail collection has almost every kind of animal butt plug you could ask for – especially when it comes to fox, wolf, or kitten tail plugs. With 150+ to choose from in a variety of colors and materials, we’re sure you’ll find the perfect animal tail for you or your partner!

SHOP TAIL PLUGS AT LOVEPLUGS

Best Glass Tail Plugs: Crystal Delights

Crystal Delights sets the standard for what glass sex toys should be. Made from hardened tempered glass and available in over 20 different animal tails and 6 plug sizes:

Perhaps the best feature of these animal tail plugs: the tails are removable. This makes for easy cleaning, and allows you to swap out tails without needing to buy multiple plugs!

Pros:

• Detachable tails: for easy cleaning or quickly swapping looks.
• faux or real fur: Both options are available on a variety of their fox and wolf tails
• Tempered glass: much more durable than other, cheaper glass sex toys

Cons:

• Price: Ranges from $80 – 120 for a a new plug and tail

Final Review

Due to the unique combination of clear glass and colored animal tail butt plugs, these plugs are some of the sexiest on the market. Add in the excellent build quality and engineering that Crystal Delights is known for, and you have a very kinky butt plug!

SHOP TAIL PLUGS AT CRYSTAL DELIGHTS

Best Tail & Ear Sets: The Fetish Academy

Are you looking for more than just an animal butt plug for your kinky roleplay? The Fetish Academy has a wide variety of complete sets of tail plugs and matching faux fur ears.

This includes:

• Fox tail plug and ears
• Cat ears and tail plug
• Bunny ears

Pros:

• Matching set: Makes it easier to plan an entire kinky outfit with matching tail and ears. Great beginner product.
• Price: unbeatable price for a combined tail plug and animal ears set

Cons:

• Faux fur isn’t as high quality as some other brands we reviewed and the quality of the ears varies from set to set.
• Only small/medium sizes – no large plugs.

Final Review

The Fetish Academy’s matching furry plug and ear sets are a great starter product for someone looking to get into animal roleplay with a partner. They are very affordable, however as a result the quality is a bit lower compared to some of the premium tail buttplugs on this list.

SHOP TAIL & EAR SETS AT THE FETISH ACADEMY

Best Rainbow Tail Plug: Crystal Delights Unicorn Tail

We already gave a full rundown of the crystal delights tail plugs above, but we wanted to give a shoutout to their very colorful unicorn tail plug line.

The unicorn tail plugs are similar to horse or pony hair, with the exception that they are vivid jewel tones or soft pastel colors not found in nature. These beautiful horse hair plugs can be purchased as a full set, or you can purchase just the tail and use it with any of your other Crystal Delights tail plugs.

Pros:

• Beautiful colors to fit any desired color palette
• Rainbow swirls help you live up to your wildest roleplay dreams
• Detachable tails mean you can buy multiple colors for any mood

Cons:

• Only compatible with Crystal Delights butt plugs

Final Review

On pure aesthetics, these unicorn tails are our favorite tail butt plugs of everything we’ve reviewed. Although we realize this is subjective – you may like some of the more realistic tail plugs featured above. That said, Crystal Delight’s unmatched product quality and the ability to interchange tails means you can easily achieve both looks!

SHOP RAINBOW UNICORN TAILS AT CRYSTAL DELIGHTS

Honorable Mention: LovePlugs Rainbow Fox Tail

We also wanted to highlight this beautiful colorful faux fox tail plug from LovePlugs.

We don’t think it’s as visually appealing as the fur or colors of the Crystal Delights unicorn tails, but it is a fraction of the price. And if you’re more into fox play than pony play, this may be just the perfect colorful animal tail plug for you.

Best Bunny Tail Plugs: LovePlugs 3″ Bunny Tails

Ready to fuck like rabbits? These cute 3-inch pom butt plugs are a sexy way to incorporate some kinky anal play with your partner.

Choose from multiple materials, colors, and butt plug shapes to find the best rabbit tail butt plug for your needs.

Pros:

• Materials: plugs come in stainless steel, aluminum alloy, or silicone
• Colors: Choose from 8+ colors including white, black, pink, purple, and brown.
• Shapes: multiple plug shapes to choose from including the classic shape, ribbed, tapered, bulbed, and more!
• Price: very affordable at just $30

Cons:

• Tail does not detach for cleaning or changing colors
• Rabbit tails are typically 3-4 inches long, so they may not stick out far enough if you have a curvaceous bum.

Final Review

If you’re looking for a small, cute tail plug then these pom-pom rabbit tails are the perfect choice! They are available in a wide variety of colors, shapes, and materials to ensure you get the perfect plug for your experience level.

And at $25-30 these plugs are quite affordable and won’t break the bank. The perfect beginner animal tail plug for your or your partner!

SHOP BUNNY TAILS AT LOVEPLUGS

Best Puppy Tail Plugs: Happy Puppy by SquarePeg Toys

SquarePeg Toys makes some incredibly high-quality silicone butt plugs. You’ll recognize their puppy tail plugs as the same base model as the Egg Plug.

They also offer 5 different puppy tail plugs:

• Happy Puppy – the original puppy tail. Comes in 5 sizes and 16 colors.
• Wag – a thin, flexible tail designed to move back and forth and wag
• Woofy – a thicker, heavy puppy tail butt plug
• Docked – a shorter, stiff tail plug
• Pug – short and curly. Also works as a pig tail. Available in 5 colors

Pros:

• Fullness – These butt plugs have much more volume than others on the market, providing unmatched fullness and p-spot stimulation.
• Silicone Quality: Soft and flexible, yet firm enough to deliver strong internal stimulation
• Aesthetics: 5 different puppy tail styles and colors to choose from

Cons:

• Not for Beginners: Even the smallest plug is 1.5″ wide, which can be large for an anal beginner

Final Review

If you’re looking to get ruff with your partner and engage in some puppy play, these are the butt plugs for you. SquarePeg Toys has been making unique, high quality anal toys for 20 years and these puppy tails have been a best seller for almost as long.

SHOP PUPPY TAILS AT SQUAREPEG TOYS

Best Vibrating Tail Plug: Frisky Fox Tail Silicone Butt Plug

The Frisky Fox vibrating tail plug is one of the few animal tail plugs we found that actually vibrates. The problem with most tail plugs is either:

• Made from steel or aluminum, so no vibrator
• Lacking space for a vibrator due to attaching the tail to the plug

This anal toy gets around that problem by adding a silicone loop near the base of the toy where you can insert one or two external bullet vibes.

Pros:

• Vibrates: add up to 2 external bullet vibes for powerful vibrations
• White faux fox tail is smooth and silky feeling
• Modestly priced at just $50

Cons:

• Vibrations not as powerful as a dedicated vibrating butt plug.
• Only one color option to choose from

Final Review

This isn’t the most visually appealing tail plug, as it only comes in plain white. That said, the powerful vibrating bullet should be more than enough to make up for this fact. What you lose in visual appeal, you gain back in the additional stimulation from the vibrator!

All in all, a fantastic tail butt plug for anal beginners or intermediates.

SHOP FRISKY FOX TAIL VIBRATING PLUG AT LOVEHONEY

Best Pony Plug: Rosebuds Horse Tail Stainless Steel

Our favorite pony butt plug comes from Julian Snelling’s Rosebuds collection. Make no mistake – these are some luxe butt plugs with the high-quality craftmanship Rosebuds is known for.

The plugs are genuine horse hair available in 5 different colors. The butt plug itself is made of 100% stainless steel, and hand polished to give it that shiny, mirrored look.

Pros:

• Genuine horse hair available in 5 colors
• Long-term play: stainless steel construction means you can use silicone lube for extended wear
• Construction: The amount of detail that went into every facet of this tail plug is immediately apparent, from the very first touch.

Cons:

• Price: At $100+ it’s one of the more expensive tail plugs on this list
• Tails are not removable or interchangeable.

Final Review

As far as horse tail butt plugs go (or any animal tail), the Rosebuds collection is as good as it gets. So saddle up with your partner and go for the best ride of your life!

SHOP HORSE TAIL PLUGS AT ROSEBUDS

More Metal Butt Plug Reviews

Looking for something slightly different in a metal butt plug? Read our full, detailed breakdown of the best metal butt plugs on the market.

Frequently Asked Questions about tail butt plugs

Are these plugs made with real animal fur?

Some are made with genuine fox fur or horse hair. That said, the vast majority of animal tail plugs are made with faux fur. Unless we specifically denote a plug as having real fur, assume that it is synthetic. In general, any tail plug less than $70-80 is going to have fake fur as it’s simply too expensive.

How do I clean my animal tail butt plug?

The plug itself can be cleaned like any other sex toy, the challenge is making sure not to damage or ruin the fur tail. If your tail plug is removable like the Crystal Delights plugs we reviewed then that’s easy. For the rest of the plugs, we recommend using a plastic bag to cover the tail fur while cleaning the plug.

What’s the best material for a tail plug?

There’s no best answer for this question, although most of the plugs featured are stainless steel. This is useful for a tail butt plug because stainless steel can be used with silicone-based lubes, which last much longer than water-based lubes. This makes silicone tail plugs great for long term wear and roleplay without the lube drying out and chafing.

What’s the best way to use a tail plug?

The sky’s the limit, but here are some quick ideas to spark your imagination:

• Wear it around the house – the added weight of the plug and tail can provide some exciting stimulation as you go about your daily life.
• Roleplay as your favorite animal – dress it up with a set of animal ears, a leash, and whatever other accessories you have.
• Dress up – no need to go full barnyard; it can feel incredibly sexy to wear with regular lingerie and stockings. Crotchless and open-back panties are ideal to show off your new furry tail!
• Keep it in during sex – more on this below.

How do tail plugs feel during sex?

Amazing! You get all the physical stimulation of a regular anal plug, but with some additional pleasure as the tail sways back and forth and the weight tugs at your ass. Add in your favorite vibrator for bonus fun 🙂

The one thing to be mindful of is keeping your furry tail safe – most of the tails are resilient to some wetness, but try not to grab the tail itself with sticky, lubed-up fingers.