Looking to go big on a budget? The Colt XL Big Boy is the our pick for best XL budget butt plug. At just $40 for a massive 3 inches max diameter, you really can’t get a bigger anal toy for the price.
Sure, it’s not the most luxurious butt plug we’ve reviewed. But it more than gets the job done for the experienced anal explorer.
Disclosure: some of the links on this page are affiliate links, meaning we get paid if you buy a product using one of our links, at no extra cost to you. We never let affiliate programs influence our decisions on the best sex toys, and the opinions here are our own. We’ve spent hundreds of hours reviewing and testing toys and this is how we keep the lights on. Read our full affiliate disclosure.
- Girthy: 3 inches max diameter is over 9.4 inches circumference
- Body safe: exterior is body-safe silicone
- Thick base: so it won't get pulled up into your ass.
- Difficult to remove due to girth and taper.
- Silicone is very firm for a plug this big
Colt XL Big Boy Specs:
Insertable Length: 4.5 inches
Max Girth: 3 inches
Materials: Silicone exterior over plastic core
Cheap, Huge, and 100% Body Safe
Large and thick sex toys aren’t cheap. Due to the sheer volume of material required, the cost goes up exponentially compared to smaller toys. One XL butt plug can use the same amount of silicone as 3-5 small butt plugs!
Body-safe silicone isn’t as cheap as other rubber and jelly blends, so large silicone butt plugs usually end up quite expensive.
The Colt XL Big Boy bucks that trend with a massive 3 inch diameter for just $40. So how is this plug so much cheaper than equivalent size silicone butt plugs? The answer is: it’s not pure silicone. Colt XL is actually a silicone outer shell over a hollow interior stuffed with filler.
Don’t worry, it’s still 100% body-safe – the outer layer is all silicone, but that’s the compromise that has to be made to get such a huge toy for so cheap.
It’s not the softest silicone for a butt plug, but some might even say that firmness is an added plus because it gives a good anal stretch.
Get a Good Stretch In
Are you an experienced anal-toy-user looking for a challenge? Everything about the Colt XL is designed to stretch you to your limits.
Luckily, the 4.5 inches insertable length has a nice, even taper to help you gradually loosen up and take the plug in. Think of it as both a journey and a destination – you can take as long as you need on the tapered bulb, and when you fully relax you’re rewarded with an incredible feeling of fullness and a good anal stretch.
Once in place, the (relatively) think neck locks the Big Boy firmly in place, with the wide base preventing the toy from pulling up into your ass. The wide circular base may be a bit big if you’re on the petite side.
But if you can take the plug in, you’ll have plenty of other sensations to focus on!
See What Others Are Saying About the Colt XL butt Plug
The Colt XL has a solid number of positive reviews. As of the time of writing, it has 41 reviews on Amazon with an average rating of 3.7 stars. On LoveHoney it has 43 total reviews, with an average rating of 4.5 stars.
The common trend is that – surprise – this is a very advanced anal toy and even for experienced players, the girth is still hard to handle. But for those of you looking for a real challenge, anal stretch, and feeling of fullness, it can’t be beat at this price:
Use lots of lube and learn to relax around this monster butt plug…
A bigger challenge for an experienced anal explorer:
Colt XL Big Boy: Final Review
It’s not the flashiest butt plug we’ve reviewed, and it certainly isn’t glamorous. But if you’re looking for pure girth on a limited budget, you really can’t do better than this behemoth.
Body-safe silicone toys of this size usually cost at least twice as much, so it really is an unbeatable price point for those looking for a cheap, safe, and massive anal plug.