When shopping for any large or XL butt plug, there’s one question you always need to ask yourself:
How does this toy compare to the Egg Plug?
And there’s several good reasons why Squarepeg Toys has an enduring classic in the Egg Plug, and why it’s our pick for the best large butt plug on the market:
- The supersoft silicone is comfortable even in the largest sizes.
- There are 9 sizes to choose from ranging from XS to ‘Monster’
- The thick, bulbous head gives you a good stretch and great prostate stimulation
- These plugs are comfortable for long-term wear, with a secure T-base
It just has everything you want in a thick butt plug. The price of the Egg plug also scales nicely with the size, and they’re reasonably priced at each of the 9 sizes.
A great butt plug, and one of our overall favorite anal toys.
Disclosure: some of the links on this page are affiliate links, meaning we get paid if you buy a product using one of our links, at no extra cost to you. We never let affiliate programs influence our decisions on the best sex toys, and the opinions here are our own. We’ve spent hundreds of hours reviewing and testing toys and this is how we keep the lights on. Read our full affiliate disclosure.
- Massive butt plug: with 9 sizes to choose from, there's an egg plug for every experience level!
- Supersoft: one of the softest silicone butt plugs we've reviewed.
- Incredible fullness: the egg shape provides unmatched 'fullness' and great prostate stimulation.
- Long-term wear: the T-base and soft silicone makes it great for extended use.
- Firmer on request: available in super-soft silicone or firmer traditional silicone.
- The super-soft silicone is more prone to creases, folds, and deforming over time than a harder silicone.
Price: $30 – $160
Insertable Length:3″ (XS) – 7″ (Monster)
Max Girth: 1.3″ (XS) – 3.6″ (Monster)
Materials: Ultra Soft Silicone
Features: Flared T-base, 9 sizes to choose from
Even the Largest Sizes Are Comfortable
First off: the Egg Plug is not a beginner’s toy.
The fact the the extra-small Egg Plug is about the same size as most “normal” butt plugs should clue you in. Then, there’s a total of 9 sizes including large, extra large, XXL, XXXL, and the aptly-named “Monster” size.
Secondly: this may be the softest silicone toy we’ve ever reviewed.
Which not only feels luxurious to the touch, but has quite a bit of give to the material. This is critical for inserting and removing the big toys, and the added give really helps make these huge butt plugs comfortable. You’d be amazed how much easier the soft silicone is to take in compared to a traditional silicone butt plug.
We’ve only used the supersoft silicone version of this plug, but they are also available in a traditional, firmer silicone for those interested in a firmer toy for more of an anal stretch.
The one downside is that supersoft silicone can damped vibrations a bit. And even though the Egg plug doesn’t come with the option for a bullet vibe in the base like some anal plugs, we recommend using it with a powerful external vibrator like a magic wand for best results. Not even supersoft silicone can dampen the vibrations of something like the Doxy Die Cast!
The Egg Shape Gives Amazing “Fullness”
The Egg Plug gets its name from the obviously-egg-shape of the bulb. This is different from the typical conical tapered look you see with most plugs on the market.
It’s also part of why we love this plug so much.
As we discussed in our visual guide to butt plugs, the egg shape feels incredibly ‘full’ inside your ass. Not in an uncomfortable way (thanks to the soft silicone), but in a very exciting way.
The egg shape is also great for guys, as any movement during sex (or going about your daily life) will press the plug up against the prostate for some great stimulation.
Speaking of movements… even the large egg plugs are fantastic for extended and/or public wear.
The T-base ensures the plug sits snugly between your cheeks, while the soft material means the plug won’t get uncomfortable after several hours of use. We’re not huge into public wear, but many reviewers report being able to wear the larger plugs for 8-12 hours with no discomfort.
Don’t Just Take it From Us…
We’re not the only ones that love this large butt plug. It’s widely celebrated by other sex toy bloggers on the internet, and a small, but dedicated user base that absolutely loves everything about these plugs.
Take the following Egg Plug review from Peepshowtoys:
This reviewer also vouches that you can take a bigger butt plug than you think due to the super soft silicone:
Care & Cleaning
The only downside we could find to this amazing large butt plug has to do with the very same ultra-soft silicone that we love: you have to be careful with the long-term storage to prevent creases and bends in the material.
But as long as you’re careful about putting it away after use, these plugs are sure to serve you (and your partner) for a very long time!
SquarePegToys Egg Plug: Final Review
This is far-and-away our favorite huge butt plug on the market. The quality is excellent, and the shape + materials of the plug offers an improved experience over many of the traditional butt plugs on the market.
Great for extended wear, and absolutely orgasmic when paired with an external vibrator. It’s also great for some anal stretching as you let the girth of the egg-shape pop in and out of your ass.
And with 9 sizes that go up to “truly, monstrously huge,” the only question you need to ask yourself is:
“how big do I want to go?”